Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Self-proclaimed Genius jettstockUnited States Recent Activity Deviant for 6 Months
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 540 Deviations
40 Comments
1,392 Pageviews

more discussions on plagiarism - fair use - (C)

Thu Jul 16, 2009, 1:05 PM
This is awesome -- it looks like (at a glance) that about half of the president of Jacksonville State University's PhD dissertation was plagiarized from another PhD candidate's dissertation. There have been zero consequences.

From the comments of that post, I found this -- a compilation of proof that a commercial artist is using vectored (?) photographs of those creepy resin dolls, mostly without permission, to create other works of art that have made hir probably a stack of dough.

Here's one of the examples, since explanations don't quite cut it:

[link]

On the left you have Mijn Schatje's artwork. In the center you have the original photograph of the personalized doll. On the right you have the doll overlaid with the art, showing the identical facial structure. There are a whole bunch of other examples with the link up there.

To me, this feels like Fair Use, similar to the debacle over Shepherd Fairey's Barack Obama "Hope" poster. Side-by-side, it's clear that the artist did incorporate that source material -- but just as a red-and-blue chalk drawing will never be confused with an AP photograph, a vectored iPod skin will never be confused with an original resin doll. I can't imagine Mijn's use of the doll shapes hurting the doll owners or designers in any way. Sie did not create identical dolls; sie created derivative works in an entirely different medium with an entirely different purpose.

Tacky and rude? Maybe. Illegal? I don't think so, but then again, I'm not an expert on Fair Use law (or any law for that matter). Stealing? I don't think it's that, either.

Devious Info

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconstellarlunagraphix:
Used stock: [link]

--
Notice: This product may contain dry wit and sarcasm. Take caution when attempting to start conversation.
:iconteeal:
hi... used your stock here-> [link] thanks a lot!!
:iconaluenda:
Hai julianz!!
guess who this is? x__x

--
I moved!
en-da
:iconlaynisample:
hey, julian.

don't know what happened, but hope you are okay. everyone on HP is upset that you left.

:heart:
diya

--
"if one synchronized swimmer drowns, do the rest of them have to die?"
:iconcauldroncake:
yo julian,

it's juliet. dude what's up? i have NO clue what happened with everyone and the blog and shit because i wasn't on the night "it" happened, apparantly. it's confusing. TELL ME.

--
Meh
:iconjettstock:
i shut 'em down. tired of the bullshit.
:iconcauldroncake:
well, i know that much... but why? someone told me that on simsnark (i think) someone posted that they laughed when dink died. i don't know if it was true, but they said that was the reason you took the blogs down. argh. did you know that the night "it" happened six people got perm. banned?

--
Meh
:iconthundermtbengals:
julian you ok? just to let you know hp got in a upwar about what happen and most were upset as well anyways hope your ok
:iconniemar:
thanks for tha :+fav: =D

--
ಠ_ಠ

Site Map